South Carolina might carry 10 or 11 players deep into the season, but when an NCAA Tournament game comes down to the final five minutes and one possession, Dawn Staley won’t trust all of them. She’ll trust five. And one of the most talented players on this roster might be watching from the bench when it happens.
This isn’t a talent ranking. It’s a championship trust ranking — and the standard is brutal. Can a player defend multiple actions without losing her assignment? Handle pressure without turning it over? Execute when one mistake ends the season?
South Carolina reached back-to-back national championship games in 2025 and 2026 because Staley could go deep without sacrificing structure. Raven Johnson ran the offense. Te-Hina Paopao provided proven perimeter scoring. Now both are gone, along with Maddie McDaniel stepping away — the guard with the clearest point guard profile on the roster. That leaves South Carolina loaded with talent but without an obvious late-game floor general, and it reshapes everything.
The Locks: Joyce Edwards and Tessa Johnson
There’s no debate at the top. Joyce Edwards averaged 19.5 points, 6.7 rebounds and 2.4 assists last season while shooting 57.6% from the field, and her offense translates when structure breaks down. When the shot clock gets ugly, she can still create a good look.
Tessa Johnson is right behind her. Her 19-point performance in the 2024 national championship game proved she can hit shots on the biggest stage, and her shooting forces defenses to stay honest instead of collapsing on Edwards.
The New Engine: Jordan Lee
Texas transfer Jordan Lee might be the most important newcomer on the roster. She averaged 13.2 points and 2.5 assists during Texas’ Final Four run, with 59 steals and 20 blocks in 39 games — elite two-way production. At 6 feet, she can guard smaller guards or switch onto bigger wings, but Staley likely won’t ask her to be a traditional point guard. Instead, look for shared initiation: Lee pressures the ball, Johnson runs select pick-and-rolls, Agot Makeer pushes transition, and Edwards becomes the late-clock hub.
The Battle for the Fifth Spot
This is where it gets interesting. Agot Makeer has the physical tools — 6’1, switchable, disruptive on the weak side — but her 25% three-point shooting and turnover rate will get tested by elite defenses.
Chloe Kitts, returning from a torn ACL, was one of the roster’s best connective pieces before the injury — a high-post passer who kept offense flowing. Her ceiling depends entirely on whether her lateral quickness comes all the way back.
Ashlyn Watkins offers rim protection nobody else on the roster can match, but that value shrinks against five-out spacing that pulls her away from the basket.
And then there’s freshman Jerzy Robinson, the Sierra Canyon legend who averaged 21.3 points, 8.3 rebounds and 3.8 assists as a senior. She has real scoring juice, but Staley trusts what she already understands — and Makeer has already logged tournament minutes in this system. That experience gives Makeer the early edge, even if Robinson’s ceiling is higher.
Why the Freshmen Have to Wait
Watch the pattern across this roster: talent doesn’t buy trust, discipline does. A missed rotation surrenders an open three. A live-ball turnover gives up a transition layup before the defense resets. Staley will live with missed shots. She won’t live with mistakes that break the whole lineup.
That’s also why shooter Aaliyah McDowell, despite hitting 36.3% from three as a freshman, sits outside the top tier for now — elite teams hunt specialists in ball-screen actions, and her defense has to catch up to her jumper.
Staley’s Theoretical Closing Five
Right now, the projected championship lineup looks like Jordan Lee, Tessa Johnson, Agot Makeer, Joyce Edwards and Chloe Kitts — ball handling, shooting, switching, scoring and connective passing all in one group. But that fifth spot is fluid. Against a paint-heavy opponent, Watkins could slide in for rim protection. If defenses load up on Edwards, McDowell’s shooting could open the floor. And if Robinson proves she can defend and protect the ball, she could force her way into the conversation fast.
Bottom Line
This is a preseason projection, not a March reality. November tests talent. SEC play tests physicality. The tournament tests decision-making under pressure. Every possession this season is an audition. The players who communicate on defense, protect the ball and make the extra pass will climb — even if the box score doesn’t show it. The ones who shine against average competition but lose assignments against UConn or Texas-level talent will find their minutes shrinking when it matters most.
South Carolina has 14 players capable of contributing. The real question is which five Dawn Staley trusts when the season comes down to one possession.
Discover more from ElitePressLine
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
